• Register
  • Help
Results 1 to 5 of 5

Topic: Please HELP ME ! Sibelius or Encore ?

  1. #1

    Please HELP ME ! Sibelius or Encore ?

    Hi everybody !

    Sorry, I know this is not the place to ask, but I really need many amany advices...

    Please help me.

    i\'m seriously considering buying a notation software to score orchestral stuff and piano pieces.

    I was considering buying Encore (even though I\'ve been told there are big probs with G-vox, but the software looks very easy to use and seems powerful, true less powerful than sibelius)

    Or Sibelius. It looks great but I can’t find all MIDI functions found in Encore.

    What do you think ? What notation software do you use ? Why ? What are strongest or weakest features in Encore / Sibelius ?

    (I tried Igor on PC, too unpredictable! ! !)

    May be I forgot Finale ? What do you think ?

    My Best regards,


  2. #2

    Re: Please HELP ME ! Sibelius or Encore ?

    Encore WAS a great program many years ago, but when Passport Designs lost something like $3 million, they had to go out of business. If Encore is available now, it\'s not a wise investment. Personally, Finale is still the best program out there but Sibelius is also an incredible program. These two programs are NOT going to go away, Encore just might again.... I would highly recommend Sibelius between the two. Ironically, Sibelius functions somewhat in the same manner of how Encore did... it\'s very simple to operate.

  3. #3

    Re: Please HELP ME ! Sibelius or Encore ?

    You might also consider Overture 3, which used to be distributed by Cakewalk and is now sold by its programmer. You can get a demo at www.geniesoft.com. I usually use Finale because I need powerful notation, but Overture is very intuitive and has great MIDI editing capabilities.

  4. #4

    Re: Please HELP ME ! Sibelius or Encore ?

    I have been testing quite a few notation programs, and I would go for Sibelius without a doubt. It is as packed with power and features as can be- yet it manages to be intuitive and easy to use. Finale is a good progam as well, but it is not as easy to use (I find myself using at least twice the time completing something in Finale)

    There is a free demo version available from www.sibelius.com

  5. #5

    Re: Please HELP ME ! Sibelius or Encore ?

    \"Finale is a good progam as well, but it is not as easy to use (I find myself using at least twice the time completing something in Finale)\"

    I\'ve never understood this argument. If I\'m going to spend $600 on a program, I\'m going to use it a lot. If I\'m going to use it a lot, I\'m going to read the manual/tutorial to figure out how to use it properly. Because of this, the time that it takes me to master the program is not nearly as significant as the productivity/speed I can achieve once I\'ve learned the program. If approached correctly, a program like Finale only takes a few days to become comfortable with and a couple of months to reasonably master. To give some idea, I became more proficient with Finale in 1 month\'s time than other people I knew who had used the program for 10 years. If you don\'t want to spend a few weeks really studying how to use Finale or Sibelius, I encourage you not to purchase either one.

    This being said, I have thoroughly studied both Finale and Sibelius (reading all of their manuals and watching the forums and websites for tips). Both programs have huge strengths and weaknesses. For what I do with GigaStudio, Finale is faster and more flexible. I do however also enjoy working with Sibelius. People often make the mistake of trying to use the two programs in the same way. Each program has its own style and organization, and if you follow this organization, you can complete large scores with either program in a day\'s time.

Go Back to forum


Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts